Showing posts with label online. Show all posts
Showing posts with label online. Show all posts

Wednesday, 16 April 2014

Doublethink and Doublespeak

Back in 2010 I set to sea to express confusion that offline activism had fallen out of fashion in a new digital world. Or perhaps I was hoping to learn to swim in that world by practicing my writing strokes – I can’t recall.

The new hope of mobilisation was the evolution into a more people powered organisation, getting the numbers and enabling people to act. Which felt like a previous episode c 2002/2003 casting active supporters into the same offline role – this isn’t exactly another chapter of Revelations.

Then there’s fragmented divisions about what mobilisation means? To the bosses it’s getting big numbers of sign ups, which means fundraising leads, like many marketing asks -i.e. income to fuel dull policy and politics work. To the folk in the trenches mobilisation is leveraging the power of the people to win campaign. Forcing companies to listen to their perception of their customers, or politicians to hear the voices of those they plausibly represent, or the media to magnify the stories of the many till those with power take heed. In summary the objectives of mobilisation was never to be fundraising targets, the goal is not to make money but to win campaigns. If the invisible elbow of mobilisation, i.e. our externality,  is fundraising then that’s excellent., and if winning campaigns encourages people to donate that’s how it should be.

So then is a blog somewhere where I’ve argued mobilisation as ‘getting people to do shit’, or perhaps ‘getting people to do useful shit’. With a personal goal of ‘getting people to do more shit’ against an organisation background of ‘getting more people to do shit’. With a nagging voice that perhaps we should be ‘enabling people to do shit’.

Recently returned from months working in India (something for a retrospective) I was lured into the restructuring of mobilisation teams, online, offline and mobiles into the ideology of the pyramid of engagement. I.e. one team focused on reach / outreach – finding new people to work with the organisation, one team focused on digital platforms and innovation - to enable people to stay active with campaigns and one team focused on engagement - to bring people closer to us, engaging them in discussion and deeper levels of activism online and offline.

Last night’s conversations in the pub about the next global restructuring sweeping our way, is the emerging role of engagement. Merging comms (old media), mobilisation (digital) with fundraising (street), and a hint of offline to do something new? Picking at the role descriptions of say an offline engagement manager, they reveal themselves as fundraising roles – probably representing DD expertise, which bodes badly for the digital roles and the collective engagement structure.

So if the passion and thinking behind mobilisation has become synonymous with lead generation and fundraising. And the new vision of engagement is destined to be subsumed by fundraising then in the battle of Doublethink and Doublespeak we need to invent new words and ideas to describe the work that we do – to give people the power to create change, online and offline, and to keep the wolf from our back.

Friday, 12 July 2013

Shards of Imagination

So it’s a funny thing what catches peoples imagination, or at least the media attention which then feeds the public’s sense of what’s important. Today’s action at the Shard certainly did that, and I wonder why? Is the audacity of climbing what is a bloody big building? The idea that all the climbers were woman – not bearded men? Was it the synergy of online and offline activism, and the live streaming Ice Climb – which was well cool? Or was it simply a slow media day?

The organisation has a reputation for dramatic actions, which over the years has grown less newsworthy to a jaded media. Climbing building and cranes, boarding ships and shutting down polluting factories is just as dangerous physically and legally as it was in the 80’s but rarely generated a peep out of the mainstream channels. Is this because the media is bored of such things or is the public (I don’t think so) or is it because our media has slipped into the hands of corporate interests who actively discourage such reporting? And I’d include the Beeb in that camp, who are subject to the most pernicious of establishment and corporate lobbying – the quite chat over dinner.

So why did this resonate? My instinct would be to argue for the digital elements. That anyone could tune in and be part of the protest. And of course the very real concern that they weren’t going to make it – so it was worth coming back for more. One of the conversations on the ground between a friend and some professional riggers who routinely clean the building was that they were simply carrying too much weight – that they couldn’t do it. Including the bloody great big banner and art installation that never got used. His response was that they were failing to allow for determination, and dedication to the issues, which went well beyond the physical challenge.

But the crowds at the base suggested that offline networking still works as well as online. That people hear what’s happening from their colleagues as well as the news and a website. And they feel the need to go be physically present. It seems surreal that the idea of talking to the crowds, or leafleting them, or even signing them up as Arctic Defenders was an afterthought and a last minute scramble. The organisation needs to remember its roots in talking to real people face to face, not just from behind the screen.

And me? Well I was between here and there, back from Ireland and heading to Bangkok to work with an Indonesian forests project. Which put me in a frustratingly non arresatble world running media footage and carrying expensive heavy objects. Which proved to be long, and hard work, compared to deploying ladders or getting arrested doing so – but nothing of course compared to climbing what is a bloody big building. I’m still impressed.

Saturday, 14 January 2012

Cynical values


This blog dates from a personal grump with the idea that winning campaigns is something achievable by lots of clicks, and that old forms of activism, should go the way of the Dodo. However it’s turned into a bit of a quest, complete with mythic overtones, to figure out what is possible online and offline to change the world. As an aside, many of the characters I’ve met so far, have been bright shining folk from the new world, and as a precursor to every conversation I warm them that I am a cynical old Brit. A really cynical old Brit, with goffic tendancies.

Here’s a fashionable theory of campaigning, which inspires that cynicism, value based segmentation.

Maslow has been dead for 40 years or more, and yet his hierarchy of needs still has huge credence in psychological circles. It’s one of many theories of motivation, and names I recall include McClelland and Herzberg, and Maslow to seems intellectual simplistic. It seems to deny the ability of people in dire situations – who should be motivated by physiological needs to do great and ‘higher’ things, clearly motivated by self-actualisation.

Campaigning, beyond the world of elite level lobbying and report writing, online or offline depends on mobilising people to do something, involving your audience in the debate, and understanding that audience. To that end perhaps there is space to characterise the motivation of such folk, but I am uncertain that one can do so as neatly as the marketers suggest, into a world of settles, prospectors and pioneers – and I see no realistic prospect of collecting the data to make such a crass assumption. If you wish to understand your audience go talk to them, if you want to shape your communications to be appropriate, go ask them how.

In any case beyond the intellectual inconsistences as to how to split our communications 80/20 between prospectors and pioneers, are we really ready to write off the 60% of the population who are settlers – if such is people’s bias, and the theory holds true.

More so, the constraints of campaigning in an organisation where decisions, and the veto, rest with the policy people, the report writers and the elite level lobbyists, it’s hard enough to get one appropriate campaign ask out of the door, in a language people can understand, let alone different asks and different languages for different motivational segments.

So while the work of Chris Rose, and others on the band wagon, remain intellectually interesting, one has to assume they mainly appeal to the prospector organisations, i.e. those fascinated by new shiny, trendy ideas. My hope is that we stay true to the vision of a pioneering organisation trusting in our sense of what’s right and wrong, remaining self assured, and having the courage to talk truth beyond such academia.

Wednesday, 4 January 2012

Dream of a thousand cats


The threat of climate change to human civilisation is obscene, and the most powerful argument for inaction is that it’s now too late to save our species from drought, famine, floods, water shortages, war and nuclear Armageddon.

Oh don’t get me wrong, I’ve not been Jensen’ed yet, it’ll be a while before I head to the highlands, and I’m confident we could bring global emissions under control. It’s just that it’d take an international effort akin to World War II, and I don’t see politicians with the guts to deliver.

Still on occasion one sees a glimmer in a campaign plan, a sense of insane ambition that is passionate enough, if popularised, if shouted loud enough, could bring everything else into place. The promise of a collective dream, that if it came into being, would prove that humanity can do anything.

So how many people do you need to create a collective dream. There are 7 billion of us living on this rock orbiting the sun, of which perhaps some are too young to breathe life into their dreams. 1% of humanity controls nigh on more wealth than the 99%, and their collective dreams have become the paradigm. So if an equal number of free thinkers imagine enough, perhaps we can evolve the superstition of wealth into something sustainable.

OK so I want 70 million people to believe in something, to believe so hard, they are prepared to do something, to create the change they want to see, and to make reality out of such clouds, before things go truly Malthusian.

Google reckons 27% of the population is online, so what 1.9 billion people, which has promise. And whatever your belief about online and offline activism, perhaps these people have the power to spawn that dream. So my numbers change to maybe 4% of the world’s digital generation, or closer to home, 2.5 million UK citizens.

In Argentina (pop 40 million), in the world of the clicktivists, 1.5 million people signed a petition for a forest law. The campaign did so, by doing everything, by making everything subservient to the campaign, and by making the engagement and inspiration of people core to everything they did. This is possible here, we can do this, we just need the internal courage, not so much of the militarists of WW2, but of the Argentinian dreamers.

As a campaign the measly internal, and international, goal of 5 million defenders, still inspires, empowers and would allow us to rethink who we are, and how we do things. If our leaders had guts, we could do this. Or we can dismiss such goals, and the dreams behind them, as unrealistic, implausible and outside the scientific method of campaigning.

We can dream, the dream of a 1000, a million, 100 million or more and we can believe….

Sunday, 1 January 2012

Dawning of the fifth world


Welcome to 2012, the conclusion of the 13th B’ak’tun of the long count of the Olmec / Mayan calendar, and perhaps the end of the world (Dec 21st 2012). But don’t panic this is simply the fourth world, which began back in 3114 BC; there is undoubtedly a fifth yet to come.

Or perhaps 2012 is the end of Kali Yuga, the degenerate age of vice, which began back in 3102 BC, when Krishna left the earth, and it’s going to be a year of climate impacts, before the rebirth of the golden age.
When flowers will be begot within flowers, and fruits within fruits, then will the Yuga come to an end. And the clouds will pour rain unseasonably when the end of the Yuga approaches." Then Lord Vishnu in the form of infant Krishna on a leaf will come to earth and again everything will start producing from the beginning
For me 2012 is the year that I can put some of these new ideas for online and offline activism into practice. It’s been several years since I’ve felt that I’ve been at the cutting edge of campaigning innovations – not since the days of the Big Ask, and if those ideas work, then perhaps that hope will return.

Equally so much lies outside my control. Inspiring offline activists to do more online, while safe, tried and tested, takes time, and lacks the Chutzpah the powers that be respect. Online to offline activism, looks like a shining path, and the idea of campaigning hubs is sound, but the process of moving more online activists offline, may be futile without the campaigns to mobilise them. Finally the new world of deepening online activism, of campaigning bloggers, raiders and online organisers is new, may well fail, but could just about possibly herald in a new (fifth?) digital world of activism.

In any case, I’ve been at the campaigning grindstone for a solid six, or nine years now, so I need to reconnect with why I’m doing this. A Mesoamerican sabbatical to explore ancient sites, rainforests, new cultures, and to wait for the return of Quetzalcoatl may well be the inspiration I need to build these new ideas. Or the rehabilitation plan to while away some redundancy money if they fail.

Sunday, 27 November 2011

Digital illusions


It's been a lot of months since I last blogged, and in the spirit of the hypocritical I've been working on a new project to encourage, cajole, inspire and support like minded people to blog about things I care about, making the best use of materials I provide, and in their own words. The idea is similar to Mumsnet, but I think I pinched it from Amnesty. Methinks it's time to revive this blog.

Internally we live in rightful fear that we send too many emails to people. This is true in the absolute, and worse when you consider that such minded people receive emails from every other organisation under the moon. As email fatigue becomes more oppressive, and organisations such as Avaaz and 38 degrees do us no favours here, the thinking is that we should get ever better as segmenting [pdf] our email lists. As if one can divine precisely what folk want to read – oh for such hubris.

We often segment by issue (e.g. Peace), but as an organisation we'll usually highly focused on one campaign at a time. So if you are a recent clicktivist, then you will inevitably become typecast by the Zeitgeist of our communications. If we segment such that we only send you emails about that issue, you'll become more entrenched as a specialist, while one suspects forward thinking, progressive folk are in the main pluralists. We lack the unwavering fanaticism of say the Tea Party.

This concerns me, if we confuse recency, and the short term fickle nature of clicktivism with a Cyclopean interest in our current comms. The data I have crunched, and the open rates that I have passed over, would provide suitable anecdotes to support such concerns.

So if I worry about segmenting clicktivists based on issues, should I have such concerns about segmenting based on whether folk want to get active online or offline?

My thinking about inviting people to blog, and connecting people together who already blog, is to develop new deeper paths of engagement for activists who want to do more online. Perhaps in activists who want to do more are already engaged offline, and clicktivists are not so much defined by the digital tools they use, but by lazyness, lack of time and/or lack of capacity to do activism for more than a 60 second burst.

Still there is that man on the Isle of Harris who wants to do something.....

Saturday, 11 June 2011

And then when worlds collide


So I’ve already rambled about the old skool NVDA related launch of the Mattel campaign, and yet what was new was the revolving door between online and offline activism, which surpassed even the unconsidered integrated efforts of Airplot.

I hope to consider what made this work, but the biggest question is how it came together? I can’t take the credit although my new job title suggests I should, and if anything it came down to wiser heads than mine, a sense of desperate ambition and a clued up campaigner.

So what happened? At the end of the morning NVDA activities the volunteers regrouped, armed themselves with Barbie’s and scattered across London to hide and photo the Barbie’s in situ. Each Barbie was tagged (a unique ID and a QR code) and the details were uploaded to a website.

With 100 Chainsaw Barbie’s in place, and the map populated; the ask was rolled out to the national volunteer network who then planted more Barbie’s in there locales. As a test we also sent some targeted emails to our most active online users (3+ online actions, one of which has to have been in the last 3 months) and invited them to either a) send off for a Barbie to hide or b) Buy a 2nd hand Barbie, tag her and hide her – depending which version of the test email one received.

Finally with the offline elements in place, the big emails went out, backed up by blogs, social media etc, to the wider online supporter base- with an invite to go hunt down these delinquent Chainsaw Barbies. The 200 ish folk who reported back were then recruited into a Barbie Investigation Bureau – and fed with a series on online and offline asks to target Mattel.

Did this work?
The integration of online and offline asks was elegant. The interface to upload the details was clunky, but previously technically inept volunteers managed to make it work, challenging the idea that there are such folk – disinterested maybe, digitally uninspired probably, but not inept.

As a hit rate perhaps 25% of the Barbie’s were found, which given the effort to buy them online, to tag them, and hide them isn’t great from a numbers perspective, but the idea was stronger that the reality. Again dormant volunteers came out of the woodwork for this, perhaps because one could do this as an act of individual activism – although it’s more cooler done with friends and video.



Online the traffic peaked at 17K on the launch day, and was dead 2 weeks later, which again isn’t as strong as the idea. What worked well was the engagement of the 200ish folk in the aftermath. There was some cool user generate content, videos, photos, Facebook pages and the like, with my only regret being forbidden to put an ask out for folk to send ransom notes to Mattel in newspapers cutouts.

What really didn’t work so well was the way the campaign got bogged down in negociations in Mattel. Although ultimately successful (a good thing) from an engagement perspective it really sucked, as we had plans and people willing to try them and this bit was stifling.

So some final headlines
  • Good campaigners think outside the box (Online or Offline) not just webbies and volunteer coordinators, and there’s a job here to inspire such folk, feed them energy and successes so others follow the shiny path.
  • Campaign needs and engagement don’t always mix well, which either has to change, or to be worked around. What is the priority here? to engage more people, and to a deeper level, or to win short term campaign goals.
  • If something is worth doing, or fun, then people will negotiate whatever technical hurdles need to be negotiated. Digitally unengaged, or disempowered have often chosen to be so and need inspiring not educating.
  • Games, online and offline, although the meme of 2011, are fun and we should do more - OK I'm prejudiced, but...
  • There is more energy and creativity out there, to do cool stuff, than in here, and we should both channel and enable more while being less worried about the precise look of the thing.
And finally, finally – the no of folk who got involved, in what was an online to offline ask is small compared to the % that send emails. This is not a bad thing, simply indicative, that as a % game we are looking to work with the boldest, the brightest and the, by their own determination, interesting folk at there. The mass will sleep on, sending emails, until the spirit moves them.

Saturday, 16 October 2010

Digital Ladders of Engagement

So I’m onto more speculative grounds here, compared to the Seven Deadly Arts of offline campaigning, but I thought it at least interesting to brainstorm some of the options that I think are available to the digital campaigner.

The predominant action seems to be to send an email to a decision maker. Usually lot’s of emails, sometimes separated by constituency, sometimes just in a mad scramble, before they can set up their email filters to siphon them into a folder, where they can then weigh them. Or in many cases not weigh them.

Then there is the ask: to personalise that email, or at least to personalise the subject line to make it hard for the filter. On occasion I do this, but I reckon most of us, most of the time, don’t.

And then sometimes there’s a big old online petition, that you can add your name to, and at least has the advantage you can print the damn thing off, and give it to someone. Perhaps yet another visit to #10 Downing Street.

But also there are some interesting things I’ve seen out there:
1)      The functionality of they work for you, which allows you to send an email to your MP with some sort of gravitas / sense of responsibility
2)      The interesting idea behind the house of commons petition site – does the official nature of it make it more serious, or simply easier to bin
3)      The peculiar addiction that is Superbadger
4)      And then something I saw in passing, tied to the Newhaven incinerator campaign (now lost), which was a random campaign letter generating program.
You simply clicked to generate your letter, every letter was different, and made up of generic campaign text where the paragraphs worked in any order. Cool eh?

Of all of these Superbadger is the most interesting / perverse, as people generate more campaigning emails, not necessarily because they care, but because they want the points. Just what we need, more gubbins clogging up the internet.
It’s kind of fun though, and raise the question of what else you can do with a facebook application.

Finally all of these tools suffer, from what I reckon should be a maxim, that the impact of the action is entirely proportionate to the effort you put in. One click, is worth about er…. one click.

So back to the offline activist:

In the training day I’m running tomorrow, I’ll use one of my stock political anecdotes (originally a Frank Dobson), but that I’ve heard from many sources.
  • An email or a campaign postcard is worth a vote in the next election
  • A personal letter, devised with care and thought is worth 10 votes
  • A personal visit, is worth perhaps 50 votes
  • And a good piece in the local media, mentioning the MP by name, is worth more.
Since the anecdote started, I reckon the value of the generic email has dropped (it was some time ago) but the principles there. What you get out is what you get in.

So how can people do more online, to creatively use their computers, to magnify that impact? I came up with some ideas, which could form one of those ladders of engagement.
  • Post something to your facebook page, tweet it to your friends, actively email something onto your contacts list, spam it on to your network.
  • React faster to our asks, sign up to the campaign twitter feed, subscribe to the RSS feed, install a toolbar that includes rolling updates, read more, faster.
  • Actively comment on the campaign blog (facebook page etc), or seek out a decision makers blog (facebook page, twitter account) and comment on that.
  • Blog for us, setup a sympathetic blog, and use campaign news to generate most of the content. Similarly set up a facebook group, a You Tube channel, your own website, BEBO group or whatever else is in fashion.
  • If you’re close to the organisation (i.e. we let you), write part of the content for the main site, especially if it has a devolved local group/network area.
  • Seek out other sites, and post links back to our main site. If necessary ask the web editor, present an argument, deal with the details and help optimise the site / news story by pointing 1000 links at it.
  • Join a rapid response team, coordinated online, that posts like crazy whenever something interesting happened. Get the story out there, fast
  • Something more here (to follow) regarding greyer more distorted arts
And / or do more. Spend as much time doing activism online, as one might do offline, and then perhaps the energy one puts in will pay off. Well at least as much, as doing it in the real world.